Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility To navigate market uncertainty, adopt a scientific mindset - Janus Henderson Investors - US Advisor
For Financial Professionals in the US

To navigate market uncertainty, adopt a scientific mindset

Marquette Payton, Director, Practice Management Consultant, discusses how the principles of a scientific mindset – including curiosity, skepticism, and adaptability – can help investors cope more easily with market volatility and avoid making irrational decisions.

Marquette Payton, CRPS®, CDFA®

Director, Practice Management Consultant


Apr 22, 2025
5 minute read

Key takeaways:

  • Market volatility can cause investors to panic and act irrationally. Adopting a scientific mindset can help counteract emotional reactions and help investors make informed decisions when faced with uncertainty.
  • A scientific mindset encourages curiosity, skepticism, and adaptability – qualities that are invaluable in the world of finance.
  • By encouraging this type of critical, evidence-based thinking, advisors can help clients navigate volatility with greater confidence and clarity.

Uncertainty is a fact of life. We encounter it every day for the simple reason that we can’t predict the future. Despite this, we tend to move through our lives without giving much thought to what might be lurking around the corner.

But when clients see their investment returns on a computer screen go from green to red – even if those losses are not realized – panic can easily set in. And along with panic comes irrational thinking.

As investors contend with fluctuating markets, economic shifts, and a changing geopolitical environment, how can advisors help their clients make informed decisions? One powerful tool is the adoption of a scientific mindset.

Understanding the scientific mindset

A scientific mindset is characterized by curiosity, skepticism, and a methodical approach to problem-solving. It involves embracing uncertainty as an opportunity for learning and growth, rather than as a threat. This mindset encourages critical thinking, evidence-based decision-making, and adaptability –qualities that are invaluable in the world of finance.

The underlying principles of a scientific mindset can serve to support both advisors and their clients during periods of uncertainty. These principles are:

  1. Curiosity and open-mindedness: A scientific mindset begins with curiosity, which helps us remain open-minded and willing to explore new ideas, strategies, and perspectives. This openness can lead to innovative solutions and opportunities that might otherwise be overlooked.
  2. Evidence-based decision making: Scientists rely on data and evidence to draw conclusions. In our industry, this means basing investment decisions on robust analysis and research, which may include assessing historical data, market trends, and economic indicators. It’s also essential to be able to communicate this information to clients without getting too technical.
  3. Critical thinking and skepticism: Questioning assumptions and scrutinizing information are hallmarks of the scientific mindset. This type of thinking allows us to critically evaluate the validity of sources and challenge conventional wisdom, ensuring client decisions are grounded in reality.
  4. Adaptability and resilience: The financial world is dynamic, requiring a flexible approach. A scientific mindset embraces change, viewing it as an integral part of the process. This translates to being prepared to adjust strategies in response to new information or shifting circumstances.
  5. Continuous learning: The pursuit of knowledge is at the heart of science. Whether it’s staying informed of industry developments and evolving market conditions or hosting a seminar to provide valuable perspective to clients, a commitment to lifelong learning is foundational to the value advisors provide to investors.

How can advisors tap into a scientific mindset to support clients through uncertainty?

Financial advisors can play a pivotal role in encouraging clients to adopt a scientific mindset by providing insights and support during periods of uncertainty.

Here are some strategies to consider:

  • Foster emotional resilience – This approach involves encouraging clients to view market fluctuations not as insurmountable challenges, but as opportunities for learning and adaptation. By applying principles of scientific inquiry – such as observation, hypothesis testing, and data analysis – advisors can help clients make informed decisions based on empirical evidence rather than emotional reactions. This includes emphasizing the importance of a diversified portfolio, conducting ongoing evaluation of financial goals, and understanding the investment implications of broader economic indicators. Through this methodical process, advisors can instill a mindset of curiosity in clients and empower them to build resilience so they can weather volatility with confidence.
  • Build trust through communication. Market uncertainty provides an opportunity to be proactive, consistent, and transparent in communicating with clients. Open communication about the market environment helps demystify complex financial scenarios for clients who are being inundated with conflicting information. Volatility can also provide an opportunity to ensure the client’s investment portfolio reflects the long-term financial goals that you have been working toward together. By remaining adaptable and ready to adjust strategies in response to new information, advisors demonstrate their commitment to protecting clients’ interests, further strengthening trust.
  • Embrace rationality. To reduce anxiety and foster confidence, advisors can use a scientific mindset to provide clients with a clear and rational understanding of market dynamics. This approach not only reassures clients that their advisors are making informed decisions, but also involves them in the process, enhancing their understanding and engagement.
  • Empower through knowledge. Much like scientists pursue continuous learning, advisors should strive to equip clients with the knowledge they need to make informed decisions. This might involve workshops, seminars, or just checking in with clients to answer questions or address concerns about market volatility. Advisors can also provide knowledge to clients’ inner circle by offering to connect with concerned family members and friends.

In the ever-evolving world of finance, uncertainty is unavoidable – just as it is in our day-to-day lives. By adopting a scientific mindset, advisors can help their clients navigate uncertainty with greater confidence and clarity. The strategies outlined above are central to that mindset and can help you create a robust framework to support, educate, and build long-term trust with clients – through good markets and bad.

Volatility is the rate and extent at which the price of a portfolio, security or index, moves up and down. If the price swings up and down with large movements, it has high volatility. If the price moves more slowly and to a lesser extent, it has lower volatility. The higher the volatility the higher the risk of the investment.